Which is the best electric cooktop?

Which is the best electric cooktop?


At this point on your journey to an Energy Freedom Home you need to replace your gas cooktop with an efficient, safe and cost effective electric alternative1 2 3. You just need to understand the different categories first...
 
By the end of this article you will be clear on the best cook top category for your circumstances and you'll be able to move on to selecting the best product. To get there we will:
  1. Outline cooktop categories so you can understand your electric options;
  2. Walk through each appliance category so you can select the best one for your requirements and preferences.
Not clear on your requirements and preferences? That's an essential first step! Head to our article, 'How can I get an all-electric kitchen?'

A brief overview of cooktop technologies

When getting rid of your gas cooktop, there are a couple of eligible and widely available appliance technologies: ceramic and induction.
 
Ceramic cooktops have coiled metal heating elements under a glass surface that is made red-hot by electricity. 


Induction works via a magnetic field that essentially turns your cookware into the heating element.


 Appliance categories

Often, both ceramic and induction cooktops must be permanently wired-in to your home electrics.
 
However, there is another option for induction if you are on a tight budget, which is a portable induction cooktop. This type of appliance can be plugged into any power point and can be stored in a drawer or hung up to save on bench space.
 

 

Below we outline the pros and cons for each option and then relate these to your requirements.

Wired-in induction cooktops

Pros
  1. Fastest cooking method and highly controllable.
  2. Can manage very low temperatures (for melting butter or chocolate) and very high temperatures (for boiling water or searing food).
  3. Continuous cooking surface with few to no residue traps.
  4. Very quick to heat up and respond instantly to temperature changes.
  5. Comes with many safety features like safety sensors that monitor temperature, automatic switch-off that turns the element off if the cookware is overheating, safety cut-out for protection against overspills, child locks and pan detection.
  6. Food is cooked via the heat of the cookware, not from the cook top itself, so the cook top doesn't get hot.
  7. Some models come with "power boost" for boiling water, stir-frying or searing meat. It heats up the cookware even faster, saving around one third of the normal heat-up time.
  8. Many come with zone connection so you can enlarge the cooking zone for larger pots.
  9. Many come with cooking timers that can be used for programming zones to switch off automatically.
  10. They're easier to clean than other cooktops. 
Cons
  1. Generally more expensive than ceramic cooktops.
  2. Only compatible with certain types of cookware.
  3. Size of the base of the cookware needs to match the cooking zone closely: if it's too small it won't respond, and if it's too large it won't be energy-efficient.
  4. They usually need a dedicated circuit, typically 20A or greater, which will need to be installed by an electrician.
  5. You might notice some noises – a buzz or hum is common and could occur if the cookware doesn't have a strong magnetic hold. The cooling fan for the electronics can also generate some noise. 
  6. Cost of installation can increase significantly if your preferred cooktop is a different size to your current benchtop cut-out, especially if you have a stone benchtop. This will be less of a problem if your chosen cooktop is smaller than your current one.
  7. A dedicated isolator safety switch must be installed within reaching distance of the unit due to the high current requirements. This may increase the cost of installation.

Wired-in ceramic cooktops

Pros
  1. Continuous surface with few to no dirt traps, so they're easy to clean.
  2. Useful for cooking foods that require very low temperatures, like melting chocolate.
Cons
  1. Slower to respond to changes in the temperature setting.
  2. Spills can bake on, so you need to wipe them up quickly.
  3. There is often no lip around the edge of the cooktop to contain spills.
  4. The ceramic glass holds heat, so you need to take care with delicate foods.
  5. They hold heat even after being switched off, which is a safety concern. Some models come with residual-heat warning lights that stay on until the surface reaches a safe temperature.
  6. Cost of installation can increase significantly if your preferred cooktop is a different size to your current benchtop cut-out, especially if you have a stone benchtop. This will be less of a problem if your chosen cooktop is smaller than your current one.

Portable induction cooktops

Pros
  1. Relatively lightweight; less than 3kg.
  2. Can be hung or stored out of the way to clear bench space.
  3. Run on your existing home power point, no additional wiring required.
  4. Extremely affordable, with some models costing as little as $59.
  5. Safe cooking; features can include a child lock and a residual heat indicator.
  6. If you have a matching pan size for the cooking zone, the unit is very efficient and running costs will be low.
Cons
  1. Some units have pre-set functions that may not match your cooking requirements.
  2. Units use less power, which means they are also not as effective as wired-in units.
  3. Each unit only comes with a single cooking zone (but if you need more you can purchase multiple units).
  4. One size of cooking zone limits the options for compatible pan sizes for efficient cooking.

Which is the best option for your requirements?

Requirement/scenario

Wired-in induction

Portable induction

Wired-in ceramic

Tight budget

 

 

Similar experience to gas cooking

 

 

Child safety is important

 

Built-in cooktop

 

Electrics do not need upgrading*

 

*Why would you need to upgrade your electrics? It's not the first time we've answered that question, read our article, 'Will I need to upgrade my power?'.

Other considerations

Larger or smaller replacement cooktops  

In general, we'd recommend sticking to your existing cooktop size to minimise the complexity of the retrofit.

If you're determined to purchase a cooktop that is larger than the current cut-out in your benchtop, there will be some cabinetry work required. This can turn complicated and expensive. Unless you're willing to spend money on a specialist cutting services, consider a same size cooktop or portable benchtop induction unit.

If you decide to install a smaller cooktop, again this will require cabinetry work to plug the gap.
 
If you do decide to change your benchtop size, you will require a trusted tradie. We've got an article to help you sort the wheat from the chaff, click here.

Induction-compatible pans

The magic of induction technology relies on magnetic bases for cooking pans so that they can be activated as heating elements for cooking.
 
Before you despair about replacing all your entire existing cookware, you may be pleasantly surprised as many pans are already induction compatible.
 
If a magnet sticks to the bottom of a pan, you can use it with an induction cooktop. Check your pans now to see if you've dodged a bullet with cookware upgrades!
Are you a wok aficionado? There are electric cooktop models that have a specially indented area for wok cooking. However, these models can be quite pricey, and you'd want to use your wok a lot to justify the dedicated cooking area. Alternatively, you can buy a flat-bottomed electric cooktop compatible wok.

What's next?

Are struggling with all of these considerations? Join an Energy Freedom Homes Masterclass and learn to identify your needs, gain expert installation advice, and meet trustworthy tradespeople. Check your Masterclass readiness now!

Now that you have selected the appliance category that is right for you, it is time to select the product that best fits your requirements.
 
Want a wired-in induction unit? Here's your next step.
 
On a budget and looking for affordable induction options? Have a look at our article on portable induction cooktops.
 
Dead set on a ceramic unit? Review your options in our dedicated article.

References

1 Levy, J. (2022). Is your gas stove bad for your health? The Conversation. https://theconversation.com/is-your-gas-stove-bad-for-your-health-186454
2 Lebel, E. D., Finnegan, C. J., Ouyang, Z., & Jackson, R. B. (2022). Methane and NOx emissions from natural gas stoves, cooktops, and ovens in residential homes. Environmental Science & Technology, 56(4), 2529-2539. https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.est.1c04707
3 Baggs, D. (2022). Choosing between gas, electric and induction cooktops. RACV. Retrieved 2023, from https://www.racv.com.au/royalauto/property/renovating/gas-vs-electric-induction-cooktops.html
 
The information in this article has been fact-checked using the following: 
Ciaramidaro, R. (2022). Gas vs ceramic vs induction. Choice. Retrieved  2022, from https://www.choice.com.au/home-and-living/kitchen/cooktops/buying-guides/cooktops
Gilmour, K. (n.d.). How to buy the best portable induction cooktop for your kitchen? Choice. Retrieved  2022, from https://www.choice.com.au/home-and-living/kitchen/cooktops/buying-guides/portable-induction-cooktops